Wednesday, September 2, 2015

All the Light We Cannot See - Anthony Doerr


Do you ever find that it's difficult to review a book you really like?  I don't read much contemporary literary fiction and I wasn't expecting to like this book.  My cousin gave it to me for my birthday.  At lunch with some of my family, everyone who'd read it, which was everyone at the table except for me, said they liked it.  Now I know why.

Marie-Laure is a young French girl who has gone blind.  Her father is the locksmith at the Museum of Natural History in Paris.  He's responsible for tens of thousands of locks.  Her mother is gone, so he takes Marie-Laure to the museum with him.  There she learns about natural history, gems and shells being of particular interest.  He also builds a miniature diorama of their neighborhood in Paris to help Marie-Laure learn how to get around the city.  For her birthdays, he builds little houses with secret compartments to hold special birthday treats.

Meanwhile, in Germany, Werner and his sister Jutta are in an orphanage.  Werner is forced to join Hitler's Youth.  He's a wizard with radios, math, and electronics, but he's still forced to participate in the rigorous training / bullying of the army of children.  He meets Frederick, a sensitive boy who loves birds and who is filled with wonder.  The army is not a good place for either of them.

As the Germans invade Paris, Marie-Laure's father is given a stone which may be the famous and valuable gem called the Sea of Flames.  There are four gems, one real and three fakes.  He takes Marie-Laure to Saint-Malo, to the house of Marie-Laure's great uncle, Etienne.  Etienne had been a hermit since the First World War, when he and his brother fought.  His brother was killed.  Etienne cannot bear the real world and never leaves his house.  He sees ghosts.  

Etienne's house is full of radios.  He and his brother used to broadcast a science program for children.  The Germans order everyone to turn in their radios.  Etienne's family complies  -  except for the powerful radio built into the secret attic.

Werner and his unit are responsible for locating and destroying any unauthorized radios.  Etienne has been broadcasting a list of numbers to the Allies.  Saint-Malo, the beautiful old city by the sea, becomes a target for both the Germans and the Allies, bombed mercilessly.

Marie-Laure's father tries to get to Paris but is arrested and imprisoned.  Etienne is taken prisoner, too.  Marie-Laure is left alone in the house by the sea.  A German officer is searching for the valuable gem that her father may have had.  He shows up at the house and Marie-Laure hides.

There's so much beautiful detail in this book.  Her father buys Marie-Laure books in Braille.  She's reading Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea.  At one point, she begins to read the book aloud for broadcast.  

In one of the strange twists that sometimes startle me, I was reading Twenty Thousand Leagues earlier this summer.  It got put aside, not because it wasn't interesting, but because it just did.  You know how that goes.  Now I'm eager to finish it and read, or re-read, more Jules Verne.

At first, I was annoyed by the book because it jumps forward and backward in time.  The chapters are short and alternate between Marie-Laure's story and Werner's, until they converge.  As I got to know the characters and understood the trajectory of the story, I felt more comfortable.  The time period covered is from just before World War II to 2014.

I have joined the ranks of the enchanted.

11 comments:

  1. Putting on my list to read! The cover is gorgeous.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope you like it. It is a pretty cover, isn't it? My photo doesn't do it justice.

      Delete
  2. Yet another to add to my list, it sounds right up my street.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I do think you'd like it. It's history and a bit of magic in the sense that beauty and wonder are magical.

      Delete
  3. I too had a struggle to get into the flow of the book but...once I got hooked into the characters it felt much better. An enjoyable read, I agree.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm glad to hear I wasn't the only one with a problem with the form of the book. I loved some of the characters and hated others. I think that's a sign the author was successful. I loved Marie-Laure's curiosity about shells and nature and Werner and Jutta's love of the late night science broadcasts for children.

      Delete
  4. I chose and reviewed this book for my AAUW women's book group at my home. As usual, I had lots of visual effects. And often teased about that. I had pictures of St. Malo before and after the war, the churches, homes, etc. It was a good book. Bought the other books by Doerr second hand. Lorraine of Mechanicsburg, PA. Daughter now in Havertown, Pa.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My google account is under Patrick! Katrina knows me as Lorraine Wacob (Scot.) Slattery.

      Delete
    2. My google account is under Patrick! Katrina knows me as Lorraine Wacob (Scot.) Slattery.

      Delete
    3. I remember who you are, but I was startled when "Patrick Slattery" came up on my Comments! My cousin lives in Mechanicsburg. She's a veterinarian at a clinic in the area, but I forget which clinic.

      I haven't got around to looking at Saint Malo before and after. I thought about it while reading the book but got lazy. My lap top was all the way in the kitchen and I was a room away in the living room. Have you read the other Doerr books? Are they as good?

      Delete
  5. I chose and reviewed this book for my AAUW women's book group at my home. As usual, I had lots of visual effects. And often teased about that. I had pictures of St. Malo before and after the war, the churches, homes, etc. It was a good book. Bought the other books by Doerr second hand. Lorraine of Mechanicsburg, PA. Daughter now in Havertown, Pa.

    ReplyDelete